Every kingdom in Total Battle keeps its own Rules of Engagement — a set of conventions about who may be attacked, when, and under what circumstances. They are usually set by the sitting king and maintained by the larger clans.
The thing to understand before anything else is that the game does not know they exist. There is no RoE screen, no warning prompt, no mechanic that blocks a forbidden attack. Rules of Engagement are social conventions enforced by players, not by software. The button works. The consequences are what is waiting for you.
What a typical RoE actually says
Kingdoms differ, but most converge on something close to a non-aggression pact with named exceptions:
- No in-kingdom city attacks except by prior agreement between the clans involved.
- No fort attacks on kingdom clans.
- Open season during Clash for the Throne, when the Conquest Point race makes in-kingdom fighting the entire point.
- Aggression exported to Clash of Kingdoms, where hitting strangers is the objective rather than a breach.
The underlying logic is straightforward once you see it. A kingdom that fights itself all month arrives at the inter-kingdom events weakened and loses. The RoE exists to bank the aggression until it is worth something.
Rules of Engagement do not apply to attacks from other kingdoms — nobody in another kingdom agreed to them. This is also why a hero who can cross kingdoms without portals enables plays that would be flatly forbidden at home. The tactic is not clever; the jurisdiction just changed.
Tile-hitting, the usual flashpoint
Attacking a player who is sitting on a resource tile or mine is entirely legal in game terms and is the most common cause of kingdom arguments. It reads as harmless — you are hitting a gathering march, not a city — and it costs the target real resources and real troops.
Most RoE restrict it or ritualise it: some kingdoms ban it outright between member clans, some permit it only on unclaimed tiles, some require a warning in kingdom chat first. Ask before you hit an occupied mine. There is no universal answer and guessing wrong is expensive.
Being attacked is not the disaster it looks like
Worth saying plainly, because players arriving from other games of this shape often over-react.
Losing a fight in Total Battle is a cost, not a catastrophe. Defenders earn Conquest Points, which is a real currency during throne events. Defensive losses revive with silver rather than gold, and during many events at a heavy discount. An attack on a properly prepared city — resources under the cap, army in a fort, surplus held as unopened tokens — takes remarkably little.
What turns an attack into a disaster is being caught with everything in the open. That is a preparation failure, not a diplomatic one.
How to find out what your kingdom's rules are
There is no document to read, which is the awkward part. The rules live in people's heads and in kingdom chat history.
- Ask in clan chat. This is the normal, expected thing to do and nobody thinks less of you for it.
- Ask your clan's diplomats. Larger clans have members whose actual job is the kingdom's politics, and they will know the current state of every arrangement.
- Watch kingdom chat before an event. Rules get restated, and exceptions get negotiated in public, in the days before Clash for the Throne.
- Assume the strictest reading until somebody tells you otherwise.
Breaking the RoE is the fastest available way to get your whole clan zeroed — not just you. The retaliation is collective because the enforcement is collective. The game will not warn you. This lesson is the warning.
Knowledge check
0 of 4
Who enforces a kingdom's Rules of Engagement?
CorrectNot quiteThere is no RoE screen and no warning prompt. The attack button works; the consequences arrive afterwards, from other players.
Why do most kingdoms restrict in-kingdom fighting?
CorrectNot quiteThe RoE banks aggression until Clash of Kingdoms, when it is worth something against outsiders.
Do Rules of Engagement protect you from another kingdom?
CorrectNot quiteRules stop at the border. It is why cross-kingdom heroes enable plays that would be forbidden at home.
What usually turns being attacked into a real loss?
CorrectNot quiteDefenders earn Conquest Points and revive cheaply. The damage comes from what was left reachable, which is a preparation failure.
0 right0 missed